|
Table of contents |
Sample ReportHere is a high quality sample report which was completed in response to an assignment in Interior Architecture. Read the report and consider how well the students have gathered their information, structured the report and written the text. The report writing checklist that follows contains comments on the report. POLISHED CONCRETEWITH CASE STUDY ON QV'S URBAN MARKET& FOYER OF MELBOURNE MUSEUMPREPARED FOR JO DANELECTURER OF BUILDING CONSTRUCTION AND MATERIAL CBY …AUGUST, 2006FACULTY OF INTERIOR ARCHITECTURE
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this report is to investigate detailed information on polished concrete, apply the research and analyse for two suitable applications. Polished concrete is an option for decorative concrete flooring. The installation and maintenance is simple, which makes it an ideal floor material for many different applications from warehouses to high-end hotels. In the report, QV's Urban Market and the foyer of Melbourne Museum have been chosen to explore how polished concrete is suitable for two applications. According to the research, QV's Urban Market is a food court, where the traffic circulation is high, and the smooth surface of the polished concrete floor can resist the heavy forklifts or the staining from oil. Whereas Melbourne Museum is an educational public space, where durability is an important issue to be considered. Thus, polished concrete flooring is good as it can remain resilient for years without re-sealing and last longer because of its simple appearance. The recommendation of this report offers two alternatives for the applications. Terrazzo would be suitable for the foyer of Melbourne Museum as it has more patterns which make the museum more dynamic. Proxy resin would be appropriate for QV's Urban Market as it has a variety of colour choices and it can still present the casual look to support the UV's 'laneways' idea. 1. INTRODUCTION 1.01 PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to research and analyse in depth the specification of polished concrete as a floor material, then to apply the findings to two different applications and finally to recommend two other alternative materials that would be suitable for the applications. 1.02 SCOPE In investigating the polished concrete as a floor material, the report considers the material's properties, its attributes, limitations, design considerations, environmental issues, BCA & Australian Standard issues, durability, installation, safety, maintenance, acoustics, cost and its lead times. 1.03 METHOD In order to complete the report, photos have been taken in QV and Melbourne Museum. Many related websites especially the Cement & Concrete Association of Australia's and Boral Companies' have been browsed and analysed. Books borrowed from the library have also been used as references. 1.04 LIMITATIONS Limitation is mainly in relation to the rigid time, which may mean some information written in the report may not be detailed enough. Besides, relying on our limited experience, it is hard to define exactly the floor material of the applications. 1.05 ASSUMPTIONS In investigating the two applications QV and Melbourne Museum, it was assumed that the two polished concrete floors are newly installed, as they are two modern constructed buildings. 1.06 BACKGROUND QV is a new shopping centre. It is located in the centre of the city. It is the redevelopment of Melbourne's historic Queen Victoria Women's Hospital site. It represents the quintessential Melbourne lifestyle, presenting intimate laneways in the urban centre. So the floor on QV's Urban Market is polished concrete, which gives shoppers a casual and traditional cultural sense. Melbourne Museum is a modern and contemporary museum. Its exhibitions are mainly on nature, science and Australian culture. The main idea is to encourage visitors to explore and discover the issues about them. Thus, polished concrete is chosen for the floor of the foyer, just to give audiences a comfortable and high-quality atmosphere to enjoy their journey. 2. FINDINGS 2.01 MATERIAL PROPERTIES – POLISHED CONCRETE 'Polished concrete' is a generic term that can be described as a range of decorative concrete flooring options, which leave the concrete surface exposed as the final floor finish. Polished concrete floors provide a reasonable choice for floor treatments, with a wide range of colours and finishes that are comparable with tiles, vinyl and cork. It is an energy efficient, low-maintenance and dust-free flooring. Nowadays, a final surface finish can be achieved in many different ways. Modern finishes using liquid polishes, latex coatings, chemical sealers, grinding (to expose the aggregates), colours, stains and special aggregates to achieve 'rock' or 'marble' appearances, are all economical ways of achieving a variety of effects. Other than different colours and textures, patterns are also possible. These can be achieved by using different colours and aggregates, with inlaid timber strips, joints or tiles forming borders around individual areas. RANGE OF FINISHES STEEL TROWELLED
BURNISHED
COLOURED
COLOURED AND TEXTURED
COLOURED AND PATTERNED
COLOURED AND ABRASIVE BLASTED
EXPOSED AGGREGATE
EXPOSED AGGREGATE WITH PATTERNS
TERRAZZO
CASE STUDY QV's Urban Market – EXPOSED AGGREGATE FINISHES Fig.1 QV's Urban Market Polished exposed aggregate finishes are achieved by grinding the surface of the slab to remove the cement paste in order to expose the aggregate or stones within the concrete or topping mix. The surface is then polished using progressively finer grinding pads. The degree of exposure of the aggregate and the uniformity of the exposure needs to be specified or a sample approved on site. Special aggregates for the concrete or topping mix are often selected to achieve the best appearance from this type of finish. Various coloured and polished granite-type finishes can be produced. Aggregate colours, types (round or crushed), sizes, minerals, etc can all be selected and blended to achieve the desired effect. Polished granite floor finishes are used at QV Urban Market. Fig.2 exposed aggregate finishes The equipment used for grinding and polishing the surface is the same as that for terrazzo. The aggregates used in terrazzo work are generally marble chips, glass or plastic, all of which are far easier to grind than the hard, durable aggregates used in decorative concrete mixes. Thus, the cost of grinding pads will increase, as they will wear faster. On the other hand, fewer grades of pads (coarse to fine) are required to produce a polished finish on a concrete slab. The cost of this should be added into the total cost for the surface finish when assessing whether or not to provide special aggregate toppings and ground finishes. Overall, the cost is less but still having the same stunning effects as tiled finishes. It is easier to grind the slab when walls are built, because there are no edges or corners to worry about. In this case, protection of the surface is required. However, if a topping slab is applied after construction of the walling, specialised small equipment (which can be readily hired), is available to grind along edges and in corners. Foyer of Melbourne Museum - STEEL TROWELLED SURFACE FINISHES Steel trowelled surfaces are used as the floor finishes of the Melbourne Museum foyer. It is usually specified when a basic flat, smooth finish is required for the surface. The usual method to specify flatness, and probably the simplest, is to adopt the Natspec provisions. It covers surface flatness by specifying the deviation from a 3-m straightedge. For polished concrete work, the higher Class A finish which requires a deviation of no more than plus or minus 3 mm from a 3-m straightedge is recommended. The level of the floor also needs to be specified because the entire floor can have a slope and still meet the 3-m straightedge flatness test. To achieve the normal 'polished' look of the surface, a good quality steel trowelled finish is usually required. This may still include some minor trowelling marks. 'Burnished' finish will often be specified and it is produced by steel trowelling until a very smooth finish and glossy appearance is obtained. The additional trowelling required to produce this finish will ensure that no trowelling marks remain. 2.02 MATERIAL ATTRIBUTES
3. DISCUSSION 3.01 MATERIAL LIMITATIONS
CASE STUDY QV’s Urban Market and Foyer of Melbourne Museum Once the concrete slab has been constructed, the final appearance showing on the floor surface cannot be changed. Like for QV’s Urban Market, the floor pattern is from aggregate concrete slab whereas in Melbourne Museum solid colour showing on the floor surface of the foyer is from the structural concrete slab. 3.02 DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
It is not a good way to use polished concrete floor in cooler climate as concrete is a high thermal mass. To use polished concrete as a floor finish in cooler climates, insulation of the slab edge is important, as this can prevent warmth escaping through the edges of the slab. The flatness, level and surface texture must to be specified when considering the surface floor finish. Flatness because the polished surface reflects light, thus highlighting any imperfections in the surface; the level to control the slops of the floor, and surface texture as finishes can vary from smooth to those with trowelling marks and other patterns. After the steel trowelled finish is done for the polished concrete floor, it may still include some minor trowelling marks. To overcome this, a “burnished” finish will often be added to produce a glossy appearance with no trowelling marks remain on the floor. However, the extent of trowelling may also ‘burn’ the surface as the trowel must be passed over the surface while the concrete is quite ‘dry’. This may result in some areas having a darker colour. Use a vibrator to compact the concrete or topping mix, or unless ground the surface to a slightly greater depth to obtain an even exposure of the aggregate. Make sure the aggregate density is uniform; otherwise a patchy appearance to the final finish will result, due to some areas having more stone exposed than others. The standard concrete mix used for most residential slabs has a compressive strength of 20 MPa, and is designated as Normal-Class N20 concrete. However, It is recommended to use higher strength concrete for polished work. For ground finished where the hard aggregates become the predominant colour, a minimum N25 concrete is recommended; and for steel trowelled finishes, especially burnished finished, N32 concrete is recommended. The higher strength concrete will give a smoother, better overall surface finish due to the additional cement content. When the water in the concrete mix dries out over time, the concrete slab cracks. All concrete will “shrink”, but measures can be taken to limit or control it. For example, keeping the water in the mix to minimum, say 80-mm slump mix is the standard, intended to be a good balance between limiting water and providing workability, and is suitable for most polished concrete work. With the steel trowelled or sealed treatment, the floor surface can become slippery when wet. So higher glossy polished concrete floor may not good for the wet areas. CASE STUDY QV’s Urban Market QV is the redevelopment of Melbourne's historic Queen Victoria Women's Hospital site. Now QV is a city within a city that represents the quintessential Melbourne lifestyle. To keep the “laneways” traditional culture that everything is to be discovered, QV’s Urban Market uses exposed aggregate polished concrete as its floor, providing a causal and traditional look. Foyer of Melbourne Museum Melbourne Museum is a 21st century museum designed by Denton Corker Marshall, exhibits mainly the Melbourne idea, the Aboriginal culture. To promote a modern and contemporary look, a simple and neat floor surface is chosen. 3.03 NEW INSTALLATION VS REFIT
CASE STUDY QV’s Urban Market and Foyer of Melbourne Museum As QV’s Urban Market and Melbourne Museum are two modern building. Their floors are new installed. Their polishing processes are much similar. After the structural concrete slab has to be constructed, leaves it there at least 28 days to ensure adequate curing, then polishes the floor by the grinding and finally covers the surface floor by sealer. 3.04 ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES --- HOW GREEN IS IT?
Figure 5: showing how concrete slab radiates and absorbs heat
Concrete is composed of 3 main components, coarse aggregate (stone), fine aggregate (sand) and cement. They are all natural materials which can be recycled to reduce the need to use more of the earth’s resources.
Figure 6: showing how concrete slab radiates and absorbs heat
Concrete floor can help regulate indoor comfort by radiating or absorbing heat. During summer, concrete floor exposes to cooling night breezes so that heat collected during the day can dissipate, which can keep the temperature of the room lower. During winter, concrete floor absorb heat from the sun or other sources, heat can then be stored and re-radiated for many hours afterwards to keep the room warmer. Polished concrete floor is easy to clean. It does not rely on any strong chemicals for cleaning; only some soft cleaning compounds can maintain the appearance, which has minimal or no environmental impact. Using no coverings, polished concrete produces an ecological floor made of pure concrete, which provides a fresh environment, not like timber and carpet which sometimes may trap germs in. It is a great alternative for asthmatics. with the diamond polishing technology, the floor does not rely on any chemicals to achieve a high gloss polished result. The approach is environmental friendly in some sense. However the appearance and quality (hardness) of the concrete has an influence on the finished product. 1 Concrete slab floors, Australian Greenhouse Office, Canberra, http://www.greenhouse.gov.au/ 2 Polished Concrete, Cubic 8, Perth, http://www.cubic8concrete.com.au/superfloor.htm 3 Eco- Living Concrete Polishing in Canberra, Toppings, Canberra, http://www.toppings.com.au/Concrete_Polishing.html when the floor is polished to granite level with a marble-like shine, it can increase the reflectivity by at least 30% and lower the lighting cost, which in a sense saving the electrical energy. CASE STUDY QV’s Urban Market QV’s Urban Market fully uses of artificial down lightings to highlight all pathways, and to give visitors a market feeling. Even the colour of the floor is in grey, the area looks very bright with the gloss floor surface. Foyer of Melbourne Museum With the light colour floor surface, it can make the museum brighter which can save energy. Besides, steel trowelled surface finishes is a passive solar design, which also engages the sustainability issue. 3.05 BCA and AUSTRALIAN STANDARDS The requirements for the level (relative to horizontal) and flatness of the surface are not covered in any Australian Standards, thus Standards such as AS 3600, Concrete Structures, or AS 3610, Formwork for concrete does not require the surface to be constructed or finished to any acceptable industry tolerances. 3.06 DURABILITY Long lifespan for concrete floor
Long lasting for the surface
CASE STUDY
Fig.7 Stones have come out
QV’s Urban Market After using for around 4 years, the floor surface is still smooth and shine, but some aggregate small stones have come out. It is one of the disadvantages for exposed aggregate finishes.
Fig.8 crack surface
Foyer of Melbourne Museum After using for around 6 years, the floor surface still look very “new”, however, some small crack lines have been discovered when looking the surface closely. The overall appearance is acceptable, with regularly maintenance the smooth surface can last longer. 3.07 INSTALLATION The first step involves grinding the concrete to expose the aggregate within. The degree of uniformity of exposure needs to be specified. Once a satisfactory level of aggregate exposure is achieved, the concrete is polished using progressively finer grinding pads. Once polished, the final step is to apply a sealer. Polished Concrete can be polished both wet and dry. Grinding or polishing wet is the original method used, as it keeps the dust down. While grinding in dry condition is easier and quicker. Grinding dry also saves on labour and equipment that is needed on a job site. 3.08 SAFETY Safety for the users
4 Polished Concrete, Levetec Surface Preparation and Machinery, LLC. WA, http://www.levetec.com/Polishing.htm 5 Polished Concrete, Cubic 8, Perth, http://www.cubic8concrete.com.au/superfloor.htm Safety for the builders A special dust collection system is used to create a safe work environment for dry grinding. This makes the polishing process faster as well. The dry dust collected is easily discarded as opposed to removing the slurry that is collected from wet grinding. CASE STUDY QV’s Urban Market To use polished concrete without any covering, it can provide a clean and plain surface to visitors. It is a good choice especially for food court area because some food may contain oil. With the glossy surface, oil is hard to penetrate to the floor. Besides, food court is a busy area especially for lunch hour, people carrying their dishes always walk across or interact with each other. It is very dangerous if the floor is slippery. With the slip resistance provided by polished concrete, people can walk safely and comfortably. Foyer of Melbourne Museum Museum is an educated public area mainly for young students or teenagers. Safety issue is very important. With the slip resistance floor surface, parents can make sure their children will not slip down easily even they run. Or although they slip down, children will not scratch too much or cause serious accident because of the smooth and even surface provided by steel trowelled surface finish. 3.09 MAINTENANCE Polished concrete floors are easy to maintain, with only regular cleaning required. The sealer prevents staining and should keep the finish looking good for years. Most sealers will last about five years in a domestic application, with recoating being a simple and economical way to restore the original finish. To avoid a build up in the sealer thickness over time, an alternative to recoating is to lightly wipe over the floor with solvent. This redissolves the sealer, evens out the coating and will restore the lustre to the floor. This also applies to resealing the floor; the solvent in the sealer will dissolve the old sealer and allow a uniform layer to be applied across the floor.
3.10 ACOUSTICS A concrete floor or slab is one of the great acoustics insulations. It can reduce music or conversation noise being transferred from one level of a home to another, or between rooms on the same level. CASE STUDY QV's Urban Market As shopping areas or food courts are always crowded with people, chatting, negotiating and laughing are very common activities within the space. To provide a comfortable area where visitors can enjoy their eating or shopping experience, a polished concrete floor is a good acoustics insulation to avoid or to block the noise being transferred from one area to another area. Foyer of Melbourne Museum Acoustics control is very important for Melbourne Museum because within the museum different themes of exhibitions are promoted in different galleries. Sometimes they may have audio or video elements to draw visitors' attention. With the exposed aggregate concrete as the foyer floor, it can reduce the noise being transferred from one gallery to another gallery. 3.11 COST The price varies according to the condition of the slab, the size of the area, the level of grinding required, the aggregate exposure desired and the final finishing sealer. Polished concrete is a cost effective alternative comparable to timber, tiles, carpet, vinyl, pavers, stencil create etc.
3.12 LEAD TIMES Time for Curing the Concrete Slab Curing is needed for a concrete slab. The longer the curing period, the greater will be the strength gain. Normally a minimum curing period for interior concrete is 3 days, for exterior concrete is 7 days. Time for Curing the polished concrete work For a polished concrete floor, 14 days is a preferable curing period, to minimise the potential for cracking. If the surface of the slab is to be ground to expose the aggregate, a minimum of 7 days curing is recommended to ensure that the surface has sufficient strength, and is hard enough to achieve a good quality finish from the grinding or polishing process. A minimum of 7 days is also recommended for toppings. Time for polishing the floor Polishing the floor is an easy task. When the concrete slab is ready, all you need is the finer grinding pads to polish the floor. Once polished, the final step is to apply a sealer. It may just need a day to finish but it depends on the size of the area. 4. CONCLUSION Polished concrete floors are an ideal low cost solution well suited to residential, commercial, educational and industrial applications. In general, it provides a healthier and dust-free environment and low maintenance for the user. Polished concrete floors come in many forms and can be used to provide great thermal comfort and lifestyle advantages. Passive solar design and long term durability can easily be achieved. Heating cables could be installed within the slab, to provide warmth to the entire floor finish of the application. A wide range of finishes such as steel trowelled, burnished, exposed aggregate and terrazzo, can be used for applications, depending on their requirement. Whenever the finish starts looking a little dull, recoating can easily restore the floor to its original appearance. 5. RECOMMENDATIONS AND IMPLEMENTATION For QV's Urban Market The alternative material that would be appropriate for the flooring of QV's Urban Market could be epoxy resin. The reasons are:
Most of the properties at the site are food premises, therefore flooring material with good chemical resistance like epoxy resin could go well as flooring at the site. Stains from vinegar, oil and grease could be avoided and lower the cost of maintenance. Besides, it could also prevent slippery flooring and provide a safe place for the user. For Foyer of Melbourne Museum Another material which could be used as flooring of the Melbourne Museum is terrazzo. The reasons are:
To avoid a dull effect, terrazzo could be installed as the flooring of the museum. Terrazzo has a wide range of colours and patterns which could be used to give a freshness and a creative design, instead of polishing the uninteresting existing floor slab. This could gain the user a great interior experience while visiting the museum. Moreover, it is easy to maintain which could lower the maintenance cost for the museum. REFERENCES Atomic Concrete Polishing, Atomic Concreting, viewed 10 Auguest, 2006, Australia, http://www.atomicconcretepolishing.com.au/ Briefing note: Polished Concrete Floors, 2001, Cement &Concrete Association of Australia, viewed 10 August 2006, http://www.concrete.net.au/viewpdf.php?pdffile=pdf/ccaa_polished_05.pdf Concrete Categories, Boral Companies, viewed by 12 August,2006, http://www.boral.com.au/ Concrete slab floors, Australian Greenhouse Office, Canberra, view 12 August,2006, http://www.greenhouse.gov.au/ Eco- Living Concrete Polishing in Canberra, Toppings, Canberra, viewed at 12 Auguest, 2006, http://www.toppings.com.au/Concrete_Polishing.html Flooring: buying guide, Home Site, viewed 11 August, 2006, Australia, http://www.homesite.com.au/indoors/living-areas/flooring-concrete/buying-guides/flooring-buying-guide Gray J. I., Lee S. M., &Lee M., 1989, Reference Book for Composites Technology, CRC Press. Grinding and polishing concrete floors, Infolink, viewed 10 August, 2006, Australia, http://www.infolink.com.au/articles/C1/0C042FC1.aspx Koones. S, 2004, House-About It: Home Improvement / Construction, Gibbs Smith, Salt Lake City Polished Concrete, Cubic 8, Perth, viewed 10 August 2006, http://www.cubic8concrete.com.au/superfloor.htm Polished Concrete, Levetec Surface Preparation and Machinery, LLC. WA, viewed 12 August, 2006, http://www.levetec.com/Polishing.htm Standing the test of time, Polished Concrete Specialists, Perth, viewed 10 Auguest, 2006, Watts, A., 2001, Modern Construction Handbook, Springer Wien, New York Download a printable version of this page (.doc)Problems? Questions? Comments? Please provide us feedback. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Report writing checklist
Report Title : Polished Concrete
Unit: Building construction and Material C
The body of the report is set out in two clear sections: findings and discussion. These sections are divided into subsections which identify and examine key characteristics of the material and issues to be considered. Each subsection begins by defining and describing the subject of the section, giving important technical information and highlighting structural features. These are followed by some examples taken from the studies. Illustrations are also used to highlight the points being made. This part of the report is methodically represented, although the illustrations lacked captions.
One point to note is that Table 2.02 Material Attributes lists pros and cons, however, they are not organised in a comparative structure. The table could possibly have been used to greater advantage to provide clearer comparisons of the various characteristics. Additionally, if the table headed Cleaning Concrete Surfaces was compiled by the authors from a range of sources, then general referencing in the reference list may be adequate. However, if the table was taken from a particular resource and used exactly as it was published, reference details of the original should follow the table.
The conclusion provides a good summary of all the main points made in the body of the report. It generally covers the positive attributes of polished concrete as a floor surface. There is no mention of any significant negative or unresolved issues which would give the report a more balanced view. It can only be assumed that these issues do not exist.
There also is no direct reference to whether or not the material selected suited each of the specific applications researched, as was asked for in the assignment brief. This conclusion only focused on generalised information about polished concrete.
- bold print
- upper case text
- underlining
Consider carefully how you will distinguish between different headings and be consistent throughout the report.
You can use this blank checklist
to edit your own report.